|
Author
|
Message
|
Bruno
Credits:
45593
My Scrapbook
My Reading List
50 Books
|
|
03.15.07 (1 year ago)
#81
|
|
Now Rotation Roster does not mean simply that 22.5 % of seats are going to be reserved
They have to specify WHICH COURSE in WHICH COLLEGE is going to be reserved this year and WHICH COURSE in which COLLEGE is going to be reserved next year
Does daktar know this simple fact
If now, please see the first page of this thread
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
|
Bruno
Credits:
45593
My Scrapbook
My Reading List
50 Books
|
|
|
03.15.07 (1 year ago)
#82
|
|
What is happening in AIIMS
and JIPMER
will Happen in each and EVERY College if Rotation Roster is followed
For example if there are only 2 seats in a course in MS orthopaedics
in a college, one will go to State Quota
The other seat will be given to ALL India Quota
And when that is given to Reservation, you cannot get that seat even if you are rank 1.....
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
Bruno
Credits:
45593
My Scrapbook
My Reading List
50 Books
|
|
|
03.15.07 (1 year ago)
#83
|
|
If you are thinking that in rotation roster that only fixed percentage of seats will be marked for reservation and that colleges will not be specified, YOU ARE WRONG
In rotation Roster, both COLLEGE as well as THE COURSE will be locked
please come to terms with reality.....
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
drpupai
Credits:
14228
My Scrapbook
|
|
|
03.15.07 (1 year ago)
#84
|
|
I hav been following the debate for beginning.............
Interesting one really......... so many hidden facts hav been revealed
But the most irritating of the whole fact is this:-
| Quote: |
would like to share my horrible experience too.yesterday, A UR candidate before me was absent and the next sc was absent .the counselling was stoppped for nearly ten minutes to "search and bring " the next SC candidate but no effort was taken to call EVEN ONE UR candidate to fill up UR vaccancy.
i think many of us would have had such experience of "waiting " for an extra sc /st to come up before them....! it was too horrible |
This is pure and simple injustice...........
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
daktar
Credits:
3473
My Scrapbook
|
|
|
03.15.07 (1 year ago)
#85
|
|
Bruno,
you are posting Questions in reply of my questions.
Read my questions againa and GIVE ANSWERS.
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
daktar
Credits:
3473
My Scrapbook
|
|
|
03.15.07 (1 year ago)
#86
|
|
| Quote: |
| Do you accept the fact that SC/ST got more than 22.5 %EVEN WITH ROTATION ROSTER |
That is the EXACT point I want to highlight.
YES......In AIIMS
oBGY Summer 2007 SC ST is getting more than 22.5%
They are getting 33.3%
BUt that is 1 out of 3 seat.
But 33.3 % of 223 OBGY seat in AIPg is 75 , instead of 22.5% which is 51
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
daktar
Credits:
3473
My Scrapbook
|
|
|
03.15.07 (1 year ago)
#87
|
|
| drpupai wrote: |
I hav been following the debate for beginning.............
Interesting one really......... so many hidden facts hav been revealed
But the most irritating of the whole fact is this:-
| Quote: |
would like to share my horrible experience too.yesterday, A UR candidate before me was absent and the next sc was absent .the counselling was stoppped for nearly ten minutes to "search and bring " the next SC candidate but no effort was taken to call EVEN ONE UR candidate to fill up UR vaccancy.
i think many of us would have had such experience of "waiting " for an extra sc /st to come up before them....! it was too horrible |
This is pure and simple injustice........... |
Even if YOU accept the ROSTER system, PUPAI.... this system of calling a SC for a SC etc , should be challenged in court.... and should be an easy case to win.
This rule is mixing up the ROSTER and SEAT SPECIFIC RESRVATION SYSTEM.
SCs can be given advantage of a SC seat only and if only SPECIFIC SEATS have been reserved for them.
Otherwise, if MR.XYZ at serial no 10 is absent then MR.ABC at SErial no.11 should get the advantage----- that is the purpose of creating a rOSTER after all.
However, understand the pitfalls of the ROSTER and the ROTATION Sytem completely before you act
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
Bruno
Credits:
45593
My Scrapbook
My Reading List
50 Books
|
|
Daktar, don't you have brain
|
03.16.07 (1 year ago)
#88
|
|
| daktar wrote: |
| However, understand the pitfalls of the ROSTER and the ROTATION Sytem completely before you act |
Please Daktar...
Don't confuse others....
There are two rosters
1. Rotation Roster, followed in AIIMS
and JIPMER
, where you cannot get a seat alloted for reserved candidate even if you are rank 1
2. 100 point roster, where ALL Seats are open till Rank 7
Both are rosters...
I am surprised that You cannot even understand this simple fact
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
Bruno
Credits:
45593
My Scrapbook
My Reading List
50 Books
|
|
|
03.16.07 (1 year ago)
#89
|
|
| Quote: |
Even if YOU accept the ROSTER system, PUPAI.... this system of calling a SC for a SC etc , should be challenged in court.... and should be an easy case to win. |
This is what I am telling from Day one.... This is exactly against which you have to fight... Don't misdirect the frustations against a good system...
| Quote: |
| This rule is mixing up the ROSTER and SEAT SPECIFIC RESRVATION SYSTEM. SCs can be given advantage of a SC seat only and if only SPECIFIC SEATS have been reserved for them. Otherwise, if MR.XYZ at serial no 10 is absent then MR.ABC at SErial no.11 should get the advantage----- that is the purpose of creating a rOSTER after all. |
Exactly....
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
daktar
Credits:
3473
My Scrapbook
|
|
Daktar, you are a fool not to see the gain in orthopaedics
, Paed,
|
03.17.07 (1 year ago)
#90
|
|
You still have NOT justified the Seat loss in OBGY in AIPG because 100 point roster was followed.
You have still not accepted this to be a pitfall of your proposed POINT ROster system
I have proved why you shud not compare AIIMS
with Aipg counselling. ...You have no logic to defend yourself ....
Stop personal attacks.... RXPG iians are intelligent to see thru u
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
|
Topic Tags: 
