Page 1 of 5: FMGE MARCH RESULTS OUT-Who's responsible?

dr_skharabanda · Credits: 1888 My Scrapbook

The FMGE March 2007 results are out again and not a great result again.People pls put in aditional info on what went wrong .......is it the National Board of Examination responsible for the repeated bad performance by setting a tough papers a some have said or it is our own fault that we are not upto the mark.

What's the problem that even getting 50% is looking like chasing 300 in a one day and we again and again look more like the indian cricket team..

Input will be welcome for FMGE 's who want to be registered in the MCI in the near future.

Cheerz.

suhasani · Credits: 2979 My Scrapbook

dnt crticize the exam pattern FMGE usually find the paper hard coz they r not used to the kind of questions or maybe the whole secnario in which mbbs is dne here at india...this exam is like a wakeup call to all the FMGE who will sit for pg enterance next to get up n start working harder instead of sayng the exam is HARD!!!!

karol · Credits: 686 My Scrapbook

its very difficult for any one to accept that he/she is the culprit... its nothing about the exam i guess everyone agrees.... we dont take it seriously and thats 2 a fact if you fail the exam had to be difficult its not Russia gde mojna platit tut bce nada znat eto ne cto 3 polychil i slava bog...neznaew ne polychish....not prepared so every exam is difficult prepared so u r ready for everythin.....

velocity80 · Credits: 935 My Scrapbook

wow!whats up with the girls getting all worked up and bashing that poor guy?all he did was ask for a simple opinion "why is the success rate so low?whether its the tough exam paper or is it that the FMGE 's are not up the the Indian standards?"
I personally feel the answer lies in both the possibilities that dr_skharabanda has put.First i'll say that YES,a lot of FMGE 's actually DO make a mockery of medical studies abroad but then again there are students who work really hard in order to live up to the Indian medical standards and to a great extent they succed in doing so.So thats one reason of not doing well in the FMGE .
But thats not all,having looked at the last 2 exams of the FMGE ,i was convinced that the guys at MCI and NBE were definitely wanting to raise the exam difficulty for unknown reasons.I discussed these papers with a few of my friends who are passouts from King George Medical College,Lucknow,and they were of the opinion that this exam was surprisingly tough(to some extent) for them too.And i need not remind you that KGMC students are among the best out there.So the point that i'm trying to make here is that its not only the incompetent knowledge of the FMGE 's but there also is another factor that is contributive of the low success rate,which is the standard of this exam has gone WAY TOO high(atleast,in the last couple of exams) for this kind of an exam.
REMEMBER this is not a PG exam but a screening test for the evaluation of the minimum knowledge that an MBBS should possess.Its very easy for some of you to say that FMGE 's are nothing but INCOMPETENT FAKE DOCTORS who undeservingly are trying to make a place in India for themselves,but you should not forget that there are guys(FMGE 's) who are easily on par with any of the genius docs of India.I don't have to prove anything to anyone,but i think its about time that the FMGE 's are given a break for a change.So just shut up rather than saying negative things about them.

dr_skharabanda · Credits: 1888 My Scrapbook

A very rational opinion from velocity80.I am impressed that a indian medico is looking at our problem "FMGE 's" problem from a very neutral and objective point of veiw,which rarely happens.

Well hoping things change and the MCI and NBE also look at this problem from students point of veiw not politically or by the eyes of various chairmen of the private medical colleges in india.Who dont wnt indian students to do their medicine abroad coz then they are deprived of their huge donations in such senarios.

Keep the discussion running people and work hard coz that the only way out...

Cheerz

dr_skharabanda · Credits: 1888 My Scrapbook

NO BODY IS CRITIZING NO BODY HERE "SUHASINI"
Its a forum not indian parliament.
keep in good spirits..
Cheerz

suhasani · Credits: 2979 My Scrapbook

this one is to velocity 80...
before u say shut up again mind ur self coz there are many of us here who can say two things back to you!!!!! an f or ur kind knowledge iam myself an FGME who passd last yr if tat doesnt satify u enough i did like to make a point here tat everytime a SC test is held all FMGE complain it was tough tat even indian students cant answer!!!! why do u compare if u think u r gud enough!!!!! hell go to US n try dng the USMLE exam which is also a medical licensing exam so why should the one for india be easy for lettng ny TOM DICK HARRY come and practise in our own country!!!!!!! read the questions sent by fellow FMGE u think they r very tough!!!
we FMGE r no less but we certainly dnt do ths pattern of studies for 5 yrs so it gets diff so why do u want NBE to make it easy.....they will make it hard for all of us here who go out n do MBBS rather easly than the rest of the students here at india i hope velocity 80 u will agree on ths point atleast!!!!!! try n boost people to read more rather than sit n critizise the system tat it wrng to ask MBBS all those questions!!!

suhasani · Credits: 2979 My Scrapbook

dr_skharabanda iam tryng to say the same thing CRITIZING is no solution i have gne thru it n come to a fact i have realised that if u wanna prove urself as a gud docter here in india we will have to struggle toooo much trust me!!! the further PG exams are more tough......so keep urself up in high spirts n read well ...best of luck to you...

velocity80 · Credits: 935 My Scrapbook

OK Suhasini,maybe my langauge WAS a bit too harsh so apologies to u.But that won't make me change my mind about what i said.I know exactly where i stand with my knowledge and i don't need any certificate from you or anyone else(except maybe from the MCI).I don't happen to be the complaining and whining type by nature,but i DO think that the MCI IS being a bit unfair to the FMGE 's here with the difficulty of the paper.But i guess you won't agree anymore coz you are already through this exam,so that makes the rest of us FMGE 's ignorant fools i guess.Here's what you said about the difficuly in your post:

"read the questions sent by fellow FMGE u think they r very tough!!! "

Take a good look,almost every question has been posted by me and i obviously knew the answers to them.You don't even know what the paper was like and still you feel like you can comment on how easy the paper was and how lame our knowledge is and how we are not aware of the Indian system.For your kind information,i have worked my gluteus out just to get through this exam for about 8 months now,and i know what i'm talking about.And I did'nt even say that FMGE was difficult all the time,i just said that the last 2 exams(even though i did'nt appear for the SEPT 2006) and this one were particularly tough,and that considering that this is supposed to be a screening test and not some PG exam the difficulty to me should be average only.
This is what you said again:

"why do u compare if u think u r gud enough!!!!! hell go to US n try dng the USMLE exam which is also a medical licensing exam so why should the one for india be easy for lettng ny TOM DICK HARRY come and practise in our own country!!!!!!! "

Now be honest,could you have said the same(above) thing before YOU had actually passed FMGE ???I highly doubt that.
I'm happy for you that you are done through this nightmare,but i still think there's more to it than just the ignorance of the FMGE 's

CHEERS!!!

suhasani · Credits: 2979 My Scrapbook

u know something velocity80 i dnt even know if u passd or didnt in ths exam..but u surely seem to look over worked!!!! i know wat it feels like when u dnt pass a exam i didnt pass my AIPGE ths time...i too worked hard for it but i guess my best wasnt gud enough too.....iam not tryng to fight with u here ya!!!! i jst want u to feel pumped up to read more if u think u knew answers for 100 q from 200 dnt u think jst a lil more will get u thru....read thru the threads abt reservation problem all thru pg exams here it seems like a nightmare too but wat happnd in the end!!!!!! people who read made it n us others said so many things abt the system n wasted our time....dnt u think ths SC test should be a lil diff jst to test the standard of knowledge we have coming from outside....nyways u wnt understand wat i feel nor will i its alright wish u gud luk in future n m sure u will pass the next exam if u didnt pass ths time...gud luck to u

		Sign In New User? Sign Up Sign in to access your control panel and messenger!
				TechZone \| SpiderNevi \| HowTo? \| Scrapbook!