|
Author
|
Message
|
salman
Credits:
353
My Scrapbook
|
Blood grp Q from AIIMS
may 03
|
08.26.03 (4 years ago)
#1
|
|
Hi
 Do u think that the ans of that Q will be -------------corresponding 2 plasma only?;as it seems Bombay blood grp only & Bombay will reject othr than Bombay(hh) grp
>  but do u think it 2 be practical as Bombay blood grp is not stored in blood bank;; & will take approximately 1lakh 86000 samples 2 match randomly 2 find another Bombay grp;; Is it feasable in emergency?
>  Can mismatch be due 2 bad agents?
regards
 salman
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
|
salman
Credits:
353
My Scrapbook
|
|
refreshing the Q
|
08.26.03 (4 years ago)
#2
|
|
A 55 year old male accident victim in casualty urgently needs blood. The blood bank is unable to determine his ABO group, as his red cell group and plasma group do not match. Emergency transfusion of patient should be with:
A. RBC corresponding to his red cell group and colloids/crystalloid
B. Whole blood group corresponding to his plasma group
C. O positive RBC and colloids/crystalloid
D. AB negative whole blood
Hi
Do u think that the ans of that Q will be -------------corresponding 2 plasma only?;as it seems Bombay blood grp only & Bombay will reject othr than Bombay(hh) grp
> but do u think it 2 be practical as Bombay blood grp is not stored in blood bank;; & will take approximately 7600 samples 2 match randomly 2 find another Bombay grp;; Is it feasable in emergency?
> Can mismatch be due 2 bad agents?
NB.The Bombay blood group is a rare group except in parts of India where a frequency of 1 in 7,600 has been observed
regards
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
riya
Credits:
78204
My Scrapbook
My Reading List
262569 Books
|
|
waste of time!
|
08.26.03 (4 years ago)
#3
|
|
yaar,where exactly does the question of Bmabay bld grp cums here?
this questions just asks u how will manage one emergency blood loss case when u're not able tp determine the bld grp (let it be due to any reasons)!!!!!!!!!!
ure just wasting time after doing the same thing over another site!
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
salman
Credits:
353
My Scrapbook
|
|
dear Riya Q was notfor u
|
08.26.03 (4 years ago)
#4
|
|
Hallo Riya
Its strange U ans in this way!I have not asked ur unwanted view dear!(Q was for particler persons,--cudn"t u read in the subject?)
> This Q came in 3 consecutive exams held by AIIMS
--so I think Q is important
>2ndly its my time ---not urs ;;so u don't have 2 worry about me
*** There r valid points for thinking about Bombay blood grp, which U may not understand(coz u don't read harrison this chapter thooughly)
***  besides Dr Himangshu Tyagi(who I think is 1 of the best students ) also think(bombay) so, has written in his book;; I just wanted 2 see if there is any update in the ans
**  U have notgone thro the book;;so u don't belong 2 this forum; 1st read the book & then join discussion, lest find ur way dear
> This forum is mainly for authors of the book-Himangshu Tyagi& Ankush Vidyarthi;; Kindly let them ans ;;  Pl don;t bother about my time
O.K. dear
regards
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
Bruno
Credits:
44695
My Scrapbook
My Reading List
50 Books
|
|
Opinion !!!
|
08.27.03 (4 years ago)
#5
|
|
After a long discussion it was agreed (agreed by us not by the AIIMS
Quesiton setter !!!!) that
If there is a problem with Grouping, you have to give only Group O (Choice 3)
If there is a problem with Crossmatching you give Bombay group ie the plasma group (Choice 2)
After reading this question once more, viewers can tell what this question says, whether the problem is with the Grouping or Cross matching
| Quote: |
A 55-year-old male accident victim in casualty urgently needs blood. The blood bank is unable to determine his ABO group, as his red cell group and plasma group do not match. Emergency transfusion of patient should be with:
1. RBC corresponding to his red cell group and colloids/crystalloid.
2. Whole blood corresponding to his plasma group.
3. O positive RBC and colloids/ crystalloid.
4. AB negative whole blood.
|
My english knowledge tells me that the problem in THIS question is with Grouping
Opinion please
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
riya
Credits:
78204
My Scrapbook
My Reading List
262569 Books
|
|
english language!
|
08.27.03 (4 years ago)
#6
|
|
im extremly sorry,salman for hurting u in this way.
i read only english language texts.
by the way,what is Harrison? 
i dunno,is it a place? or is it a new competitor of Mc donalds!
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
Bruno
Credits:
44695
My Scrapbook
My Reading List
50 Books
|
|
|
08.27.03 (4 years ago)
#7
|
|
Original Post
| Quote: |
Hallo Riya
Its strange U ans in this way!I have not asked ur unwanted view dear!(Q was for particler persons,--cudn"t u read in the subject?)
> This Q came in 3 consecutive exams held by AIIMS
--so I think Q is important
>2ndly its my time ---not urs ;;so u don't have 2 worry about me
*** There r valid points for thinking about Bombay blood grp, which U may not understand(coz u don't read harrison this chapter thooughly)
*** besides Dr Himangshu Tyagi(who I think is 1 of the best students ) also think(bombay) so, has written in his book;; I just wanted 2 see if there is any update in the ans
** U have notgone thro the book;;so u don't belong 2 this forum; 1st read the book & then join discussion, lest find ur way dear
> This forum is mainly for authors of the book-Himangshu Tyagi& Ankush Vidyarthi;; Kindly let them ans ;; Pl don;t bother about my time
O.K. dear
regards |
Translated to English by Bruno
Hello Riya
It is strange you answer in this way! I have not asked your unwanted view dear!(Question was for particular persons,--couldn't you read in the subject ?)
> This Question came in 3 consecutive exams held by AIIMS
--so I think Question is important
>secondly its my time ---not yours ;;so you don't have to worry about me
*** There are valid points for thinking about Bombay blood group, which you may not understand( because you don't read harrison this chapter thoroughly)
*** Besides Dr Himangshu Tyagi (who I think is 1 of the best students ) also thinks(bombay) so, has he written in his book;; I just wanted to see if there is any update in the answer
** You have not gone through the book;;so you don't belong to this forum; first read the book & then join discussion, lest find your way dear
> This forum is mainly for authors of the book-Himangshu Tyagi& Ankush Vidyarthi;; Kindly let them answer ;; :Please Please don't bother about my time
O.K. dear
regards
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
salman
Credits:
353
My Scrapbook
|
|
|
08.27.03 (4 years ago)
#8
|
|
Hi
I am poor in english
>where's written in Q there is falult in grouping!they cannot match
>it clear in the q -------------1)there is mismatch;;; these lead 2 the staffs think that 2)there is fault in grouping(restricted knowledge of Staffs)
> can't u read the word as in the Q ?
> I am pretty convinced! u all ralso convinced!
> If u have the concept of Bloodbank staffs --U will think there can't be mismatch-there is fault in grouping!
But if u r Doctor, u will think mismatch is posible, & will order a bombay immediately
> Finally we all have done internships , have u ever seen a blood bnk canot group?;;; the pt. party will feed the bank with sweets I think!
* what's the role of bloodbank then? :P selling blood in BLACK 2 vampires
Can we have a view of Dr HIMANgshu Tyagi?
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
Bruno
Credits:
44695
My Scrapbook
My Reading List
50 Books
|
|
Where ???
|
08.28.03 (4 years ago)
#9
|
|
You say
| Quote: |
| where's written in Q there is falult in grouping:cry: |
Please read the question
A 55-year-old male accident victim in casualty urgently needs blood. The blood bank is unable to determine his ABO group, as his red cell group and plasma group do not match. Emergency transfusion of patient should be with:
1. RBC corresponding to his red cell group and colloids/crystalloid.
2. Whole blood corresponding to his plasma group.
3. O positive RBC and colloids/ crystalloid.
4. AB negative whole blood.
Where is it written in the question paper that there is a problem with Cross Matching
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
salman
Credits:
353
My Scrapbook
|
|
|
08.28.03 (4 years ago)
#10
|
|
A 55-year-old male accident victim in casualty urgently needs blood. The blood bank is unable to determine his ABO group, as his red cell group and plasma group [b]do not match. [/b]
> That's all dear bruno;; no more this Q;;I cudn't find anywhere they cud not get the grps of RBC & Plasma
> I am also disgusted , not 2 find any of authors of the book here after so many posts
|
|
|
Post Options:
Reply
Add
Forward
Report
New
|
|
Back to top
|
|
|
Topic Tags: 
