see your advertisement here
Mobile (PDA) gre ielts gpvts mrcgp mrcog mrcp mrcpath mrcpch mrcs plab toefl usmle Forums FAQ | Help

RxPG - the perfect Rx for medical Post Graduate entrance blues!		 Sign In
New User? Sign Up
Sign in to access your control panel and messenger!		  

TechZone | SpiderNevi | HowTo? | Scrapbook!

    

DocIndia Forum - Site Related Discussions - Shouts - Library - Lists - Categories  

 Revision Tools: Eponyms Facts Diseases Syndromes Pathognomics Images Crammer Vocabulary PreviousPapers OSCE Busters GRE
 Features Forums Articles Downloads Mnemonics Dictionary Reviews Videos Submit Articles

ZONES>> Hot : MBBS : PrePG : MCQs : Careers : Alt+C : UK : USA : Australia : Canada : Global : OffBeat!

 [ Customise this Navigation Bar ]

Alerts - Study Partner - Answers - Seat Reviews - I See - Search Forums | Top Reads Book Shop  

 
 Home > > Forums Email this page
RxPG :: View topic - Davidson's Vs Harrison  
 
III MBBS Forum FAQ - Hot - Unanswered
Page 1 of 1: Davidson's Vs Harrison
Thread Info | Related Topics | Wiki Page for This Topic | Topic Tags:
Home -> Forums -> III MBBS -> Davidson's Vs Harrison
Post new topic   Reply to topic   Printer-friendly version
 Page 1 of 1
Author Message
mynameSend an Instant Message to myname  




Credits: 980

My Scrapbook


Quick Scroll Davidson's Vs Harrison 04.05.08 (1 month ago) #1
Which Book (Davidson's or Harrison's) would be better for Internal medcicine from a third year student perspective....pls reply!
Post Options: Reply Add Forward Report New
Back to top

Top of page


mynameSend an Instant Message to myname  




Credits: 980

My Scrapbook


Quick Scroll ????? 04.07.08 (1 month ago) #2
Why dont anyone reply......any expert views from those who have read both the books??
Post Options: Reply Add Forward Report New
Back to top

Top of page

bvgSend an Instant Message to bvg  




Credits: 171

My Scrapbook


Quick Scroll 04.07.08 (1 month ago) #3
well m in the same state. don knw wat buk 2 study.davidson or harrison?many seniors suggest harrison but i crsly hav nt decided.can any1 pl post a suitable reply soon.
Post Options: Reply Add Forward Report New
Back to top

Top of page

jack_05Send an Instant Message to jack_05  




Credits: 111

My Scrapbook


Quick Scroll 04.21.08 (24 days ago) #4
Davidson is best.
At least you can reproduce the answers by the tabular colm. given in davidson.
Harrison is too vast for UG level and not exam oriented. however for PG entrance exam its good.
Post Options: Reply Add Forward Report New
Back to top

Top of page

subhaSend an Instant Message to subha  




Credits: 240

My Scrapbook


Quick Scroll 04.21.08 (24 days ago) #5
i hav bought Davidson as sehiors told its good 4 ug. But how can we complete Harrison during our intern if we hav not touched it b4? pl reply.
Post Options: Reply Add Forward Report New
Back to top

Top of page

thinkerSend an Instant Message to thinker  




Credits: 165

My Scrapbook


Quick Scroll D vs H 05.04.08 (11 days ago) #6
H is THE BIBLE.........nothing can beat tht book........... if u can start off with it.....yes .....u should...........it ll be of gr8 help for PGET......
davidson isnt bad but its like a vegetable market.......keep hunting life long.........i find it quite a pain.........painfully incomplete in some places.........
tc
Post Options: Reply Add Forward Report New
Back to top

Top of page

sunkstSend an Instant Message to sunkst  




Credits: 210

My Scrapbook


Quick Scroll 05.04.08 (11 days ago) #7
I think that Harrison's is the Gold standard for medicine. But as for its suitability for UG; well it depends on the individual. If you are the studious type that is a voracious reader and also consistent, then Harrison's is for you.

On the other hand if you are not the studious consistent reader and if you find it difficult to contextualise all the info in Harrison's; davidson's gives a comprehensive yet succinct coverage of Medicine at the UG level. However if ou are interested in PG Medicine; I recommend that you start with the Harrison's and get familiar with it.
Post Options: Reply Add Forward Report New
Back to top

Top of page

dom20321Send an Instant Message to dom20321  




Credits: 111

My Scrapbook


Quick Scroll 05.11.08 (5 days ago) #8
Davidsons is much better for you in bmbs as it is the right level of depth, plus is a great book in especially in terms of clinical approach to problem solving
Post Options: Reply Add Forward Report New
Back to top

Top of page

 Page 1 of 1
Thread Information  :  Email this thread  :  Printer Friendly  :  Terms of Service  
Post new topic   Reply to topic   Printer-friendly version

Related Discussion Topics
Sticky: RxPG Exclusive Report - Job Situation In United Kingdom - 71 replies
temporal arteritis - 15 replies
somebody plz reply - 4 replies
FAQ: What will be my rank? - 9 replies
PLEASE REPLY!!!!!! - 7 replies
PLEASE HELP US - 9 replies
breathlesssssssss - 19 replies
books - 3 replies
query regarding preperation for MAHE - 23 replies
AFMC etc. - 3 replies
am i elidgible for dnb june 2004 - 2 replies
another teaser! - 11 replies
Thread Options: Quick Reply  :  Start New Topic  :  Printer Friendly Version  :  Add this post to My Forum

Home -> Forums -> III MBBS -> Davidson's Vs Harrison
Server Status: NORMAL, 239 pages served in last minute. Page generation time: 2.362 seconds



Site Maps: [Books] [News] [Forums] [Reviews] [Mnemonics]

sitemap - top30 - centuries - testimonials


About Us :: Disclaimer :: Contact Us :: Report Abuse :: Terms of Services :: Privacy Policy

Advertise with RxPG!

What is XML?

Made in India by RxPG Medical Solutions Private Limited